Effort: ~1.5 hrs · Fee: $300 ex GST · Finding bonus: $100 per accepted defect, graded (wrong figure in scope / silent default / missing refusal / documentation)
Provisions
ss 102-5 (method statement), 102-10, 102-15 (prior-year losses), 108-10 (collectable losses quarantined; order of application), 960-20(1); the file header’s scope and refusal list; Parts B (refusals) and C (missing inputs).
Rules and scenarios to trace
Rules: Parts B, C, G, I.
Scenarios: s7 (loss ordering; 9,000 vs 11,000), s8, s9, s10 (prior losses exceed), s26, s27 (quarantined), s28, s53 (general loss against collectable gain), s54 (loss-year strictness), s61/s62 (asset character missing or contradictory), s29–s41 (one refusal each).
What we most want
- Q2, the headline: s 102-5 step 1 note 1 and step 2 note 2 leave loss order to the taxpayer; the file encodes the minimising order. Acceptable default, or must it be an input?
- Q3: mixed discount percentages with losses; the file refuses rather than chooses.
- Q4, Q15: prior-year losses as inputs; is the total remaining enough for a return?
- Scope: any case that should refuse but does not, or refuses when it need not.
Common to every family page
- File:
cgt_a1.lev1.2, SHA-2563cdb679a…2ad00, reasoner LogicalEnglish2bc5cb5d1…, SWI-Prolog 9.0.4. 114 rules, 62 fictional scenarios, 163 embedded tests, every expected figure worked by hand from the Act above its scenario. No software to run. - Reviewer pack:
COVER_NOTE.md,HOW_TO_READ.md,VERDICT_FORM.mdv1.2.1 (fill in only the rows for your family plus §3, §11 and §12),open_questions.md,scenario_table.md, and the canonicalcgt_a1.le. - Paid for the review whatever you find. A clean family earns the same as one with three defects; an accepted defect earns the finding bonus on top. Paid whether or not you sign.
- Status shown on the file: ◻ unreviewed until signatures exist on this hash (see 14f).
- Out of scope (the file refuses these with a reason): main residence, Div 152, roll-overs, deceased estates, foreign residents at the event, indexation, events other than A1, K7, Subdiv 115-C, life insurance companies, pre-9 May 2012 foreign residency periods, substituted accounting periods, leases granted.
- Attestation and signature: §11 (your own judgement; AI use disclosed) and §12 (do you sign this hash for the scope in its header: yes / no / yes once findings N–M are fixed). A “yes” from a family reviewer is recorded as a signature for the whole file, so answer §12 only if you have read the whole file; otherwise answer “no” and consider 14f.
How we work
Rules, models and human judgement — how LodgeiT writes tax law as Logical English. This is a rule-review bounty, like Bounties #11 and #12: you check the law written out as rules, not a calculator, and tell us whether we stated it correctly. No software to install.
Your deliverable
The filled-in VERDICT_FORM.md (v1.2.1) — complete the row(s) for this family in §2, plus §3 (break-it), §11 (attestation) and §12 (signature) — attached to an email to support@lodgeit.net.au. Free-form prose is equally acceptable. §12 is a separate act from the verdict, and you are paid for the review whatever you answer there.